It is larger than the 2007 pet food recall class action settlement by $8 million. so that answers why it was not recalled! As example…if a pet food ingredient supplier sold an ingredient to a pet food manufacturer that was contaminated with Salmonella, and the end product (the pet food) tested positive for Salmonella – only the pet food would be held accountable, not the ingredient provider. Even if all you can spare is $1 it will help keep the website alive. Whats good for the goose……. For one thing actual, known false advertising is criminal, pure and simple. Blue Buffalo is involved in a class action lawsuit regarding the contamination of lead in some of their products. And it fails. Blue Buffalo responded with a counter suit, saying that Purina was … Susan Thixton UPDATE 3/28/18: The class action lawsuit against Blue Buffalo Pet Products has been dismissed. Many of these issues should be caught by state and federal regulatory authorities long before the products reach consumers. It is the final responsibility of the food manufacturer to have lots tested all throughout the process. Cats are obligate carnivores and can ONLY eat eat. Blue Buffalo is the latest pet food to be hit with a wave of consumer complaints alleging that pets became ill and, sometimes, died after eating it, even t What the hell is going on that the law, is no longer the law, across the board! They decided to use a questionable supplier who burned them in the past. No State or Federal authority required Blue Buffalo to recall the mislabeled pet foods. BB DOES in fact have its own manufactoring plant NOW. The suit alleges that Blue Buffalo intentionally misled consumers about using chicken byproduct in Blue Buffalo pet food. Blue Buffalo’s announcement of a $32 million consumer class action settlement – the largest pet food class action settlement ever – comes a full seven months after Blue admitted mislabeling products and 19 months after Purina sued Blue … What’s the Difference Between Livestock Feed and Pet Food? And yes W-E needs to be brought to task. Which says enough them as a company. Instead, Poisoned Pets' advocacy work is funded by private individuals, not the pet food industry, nor any other private or public institution. woul you let me know if you got it? This prompted a recall of all their canned dog food, all cans of their Spa Select canned cat food, all dog treats, and Blue Buffalo Spa Select Kitten dry food. They may be able to help find an attorney who specializes in filing the first ever class action lawsuits and to file civil suits against all employees as well. In the end it was positioned incorrectly. Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email. Realizing that the inclusion of by-product meal now has potential legal consequences, Diversified Ingredients expressed alarm to Wilbur-Ellis and a way to respond to the kibble crisis: “I think if we work together, we can band-aid this situation,” Diversified’s Collin McAtee wrote on May 15 to Darwin Rusu of Wilbur-Ellis. They have the audacity suing Blue for false advertising, yet THEY poisoned & seriously hurt, maimed, & killed! They allege that Blue Buffalo misled its customers by claiming its pet food products did not contain any chicken by-products, corn, or grain and led them to pay premium prices for the pet food. laughable. Blue Buffalo products are more expensive than many other pet foods, but the makers of Blue Buffalo claim that the extra cost is justified because their products are healthy and nutritious for dogs and/or consistent with their dietary needs. Do you know what the differences are between Feed Grade and Human Grade pet food? In May of 2014, Purina Pet Food filed a lawsuit against Blue Buffalo claiming Blue’s pet food contained by-products when Blue’s advertising proclaimed ‘No Chicken/Poultry By-Product Meals’. Blue Buffalo was involved in the nationwide melamine recalls. One – the supplier should’ve been aware (according to BB’s advertising) that their product was contradicting advertising. And not meant to dispute anyone agreeing that BB was responsible. Unfortunately, feeding our pets is not as simple as table food. when you buy an ingredient from a supplier you believe that is what you are purchasing. Click Here for more information on reporting to FDA. I have been feeding my dogs Blue Wilderness for YEARS! In May, e-mails between a Blue Buffalo ingredient broker (Diversified Ingredients) and a major supplier (Wilbur-Ellis) suggest strongly that they did indeed sell pet food containing a by-product meal. There was a TON of trouble with the CAPTCHA for this article. As the pet food versus pet food lawsuit continued, we learned that Blue Buffalo did indeed contain by-products however the blame was placed on an ingredient provider – Wilbur Ellis corporation. on December 20 2015,she had to be put down, at the Emergency Clinic in Latham at 12:30 AM, she collapsed completely , extreme lathargic the Vet told me she was anemic, bleeding inside, and no treatment would help her ,now I believe all the years she had difficulty with bowels and standing may have been the food and treats she ate. In fact BB actually had a pretty good shot for a solid reputation until this debacle and even worse that they admitted so with such a large settlement. I’m glad they have to pay a huge lawsuit. I tell you what I will never use Blue ever again!! Whose ultimate responsibility is it for the final products that consumers purchase (the ingredient providers or the pet food manufacturer or both)? Judicial Panel on Multidistrict Litigation in re: Blue Buffalo Company, Ltd., Marketing and Sales Practices Litigation. I fed my Maltese 13 yr old, Blue Buffalo from her birth 2002, she had many problems, the Vet called it arthritis, and allergies, she had difficulty walking, ,diarrhea so she was on the chicken and rice canned Blue Buffalo, no change ,many visits to the Vet. When I went to the vet, the tech already knew what I was feeding him. Blue Buffalo did not voluntarily issue a recall of their pet foods – despite admitting publicly the foods were mislabeled (contained by-product meal instead of chicken meal as was stated on the pet food labels). The FDA confirmed the presence of melamine in rice protein concentrate in Blue Buffalo foods. Blue Buffalo then claimed they were duped by their supplier, by publicly revealing that contrary to prior assurances, Blue Buffalo admitted that ingredients from their supplier did contain poultry by-product meal after all — proving that the central allegations in Purina’s false advertising lawsuit against them. Purina filed a lawsuit against Blue Buffalo on May 6, 2014 for false advertising. The fact that even the horrible stuff these manufacturers do provide can be even further tainted, without the pet food manufacturer knowing it, is beyond the pale. I believe that Blue Buffalo is solely responsible for this cost. Petsumer Report tells the ‘rest of the story’ on over 3000 cat foods, dog foods, and pet treats. You’re assured the airbag is in working order. I’m not trying to distinguish the seriousness of either situation (2007 recall versus BB’s false advertising) but the circumstances (and therefore the guilt) are based on two different premises. Although the pet food companies settled that case the following year, related legal issues continued. A proposed class action lawsuit filed in California against Blue Buffalo Pet Products, Inc. alleged that the dog food manufacturer knowingly made, marketed, and sold dog food contaminated with material and significant levels of lead. Is there any other brand that is more reliable? But we live in the real world, and 100% testing (versus sampling) probably wasn’t or isn’t happening. Fortunately the CHICKEN by product meal used was not a dangerous or deadly ingredient, unlike some other stone throwing compainies and suppliers have used in the past. Blue has the option of having one of their own employees present at the time the ingredients for their products arrive at the co-packer for testing as well as have this, or other, brand employee present and observing the entire product manufacturing process. It would be very interesting to see what “would” be revealed during a public lawsuit. It is larger than the 2014 class action settlement of Waggin Train jerky treats by $25.5 million. Judicial Panel on Multidistrict Litigation in re: Blue Buffalo Company, Ltd., Marketing and Sales Practices Litigation. They never even would be in this mess with this lawsuit from Purina, if they had chosen to do the right thing from the start. Pets also end up in the vet clinic when well meaning owners did not do their research before feeding them human food because of “if it’s good enough for me” misguided logic. BB has lost my confidence along the way for many reasons but this was the cherry on the top of the heap. Where is your own acceptance of responsibility to the many pets that died from consuming Waggin Train jerky treats? Originally published May 7, 2014 at 3:57 pm Updated May 8, 2014 at 6:58 am . Unfortunately, since 2015 the pet food from Blue Buffalo has been receiving many complaints and been dealing with some lawsuits. From this exchange, you would guess that BB knew more about their supplier (even perhaps as an agreement between the highest officials of both companies in contract) than BB ever admitted. The Blue Buffalo pet food company has entered into a settlement agreement in the consumer class action lawsuit brought against them (basically a false advertising lawsuit). Learn how your comment data is processed. This settlement is more of a reflection of that than anything. Cats that consume large amounts of red tuna in particular are more prone to this painful condition. I don’t think you can financially compare the 2007 pet food recall to this settlement. Instead, the scandal is swept under the rug to avoid exposure. By . From ingredient arrival to finished product, a brand has many options to help assure quality of their finished product. They could have easily re -couped their losses, through not only their lawsuit against Wilbur Ellis, but they could have donated the foods voluntarily recalled to shelters, rescues, & food pantries, & gotten a substantial tax right-off for it as well. Now, they have lost millions, & tarnished their reputation. But didn’t the pet owners in the 2007 pet food recall class action deserve every dime back they spent on vet bills? Blue Buffalo should be held accountable for their actions of false advertising. Didn’t the Waggin Train jerky treat class action pet owners deserve every dime back they spent on vet bills? This agency needs to really be gutted! The family-owned company out of Wilson, Connecticut started back in 2002 . this is the dumbest lawsuit i have ever seen. What happened in 2007 was sadly unfortunate but unforeseen and certainly not intentional by the USA manufacturers. The Blue Buffalo pet food company has entered into a settlement agreement in the consumer class action lawsuit brought against them (basically a false advertising lawsuit). True, PF manufacturers should have been, and should have learned since then to be testing every batch/lot for purity control. General Mill’s (GIS) Blue Buffalo dog food has come under fire in a lawsuit, claiming it causes weight gain in dogs despite its healthy advertising. litigation america. A year ago, pet owners watched as Purina and Blue Buffalo, two pet food manufactures, slapped each other with lawsuits. And my comment had to be resubmitted at least 7 times. Not much. Chinese imports? It is safe to assume that Blue Buffalo was aware, at some point, that their pet food did contain the vilified ingredient they based their marketing claim on, when during pretrial discovery—the process by which litigants demand internal documents and communications that could become evidence—e-mails revealed that Purina claims reinforce its allegations. New Study Finds 8% of Pet Owners Have Eaten Pet Food, You’re Paying for Real Meat but You’re Getting Meat Powder, You Can’t Put Perfume on Condemned, Diseased, Decomposing Byproducts. The difference is in the ingredients we use and don't use. I am not an attorney but all offices are bound under code of ethics and law and every employee can be sued civilly. Blue Buffalo sued for misleading marketing New lawsuit challenges Blue Buffalo’s claims of “protein-rich” stating a “small bowl” of Blue Buffalo dog food “contains more carbohydrate than a wild grey wolf is likely to consume in an entire lifetime.” They did autopsys on many different animals that died and there was nothing wrong with the dog it was the diet that killed them. Seriously! It is the manufacturer’s responsibility, not the supplier’s to inspect the ingredients before being allowed into the manufacturer’s plant. that ingredient then goes into the final product. Referring to a “smoking gun,” McAtee added, “If you are going to fill these contracts for any reason, then I’m going to have to go to Blue Buffalo to address the breach of contract and undoubtedly divulge the details of what was shipped and the possibility that Rosser’s material is the smoking gun for their problems. She was seen by several vets at the Oakwood Vet Clinic,they didn’t know what was wrong with her, I lost my sweet baby just before Christmas, 2015.j. Instead, tests indicated the products contained several signature elements of poultry by-product meal: eggshell, raw feather, and leg scale. 30 Day Satisfaction Guarantee. We can assume that the settlement amount – $32 million – is based on the number of consumers in the multiple class action lawsuits and based on how many bags of pet foods they purchased (how much money the consumers spent) on mislabeled pet foods. You may find that it never happens again if you used canned instead. Susan’s List of trusted pet foods. So…is Wilbur Ellis selling Blue Buffalo the wrong ingredient – Blue Buffalo’s responsibility or the ingredient provider’s responsibility? i believe it is the supplier of the products fault. Questions: Should Blue Buffalo be able to sue the ingredient supplier for the $32 million settlement amount (or more)? No pets became ill, and no pets died due to Blue Buffalo products containing by-product meal instead of chicken meal (to my knowledge). This Blue Buffalo settlement agreement with consumers (for mislabeled pet foods) is the largest pet food class action settlement in history. Purina claimed they had laboratory testing proving some varieties of Blue Buffalo pet foods contained materials that are by-products. Judie, consuming too much tuna can cause your cat to develop a Vitamin E deficiency, leading to an inflammation of the fatty tissue, a condition known as steatitis (“yellow fat disease”). Blue Promise ” from Blue Buffalo to her pets ; can she be included in settlement! Recall the mislabeled pet foods that is what you are feeding your cat more than cans of!... You ever notified of the heap aware ( according to BB ’ s blue buffalo cat food lawsuit Worse than you Think differences between... Test what they always do nationwide melamine recalls not share posts by email a lot to.! Contradicting advertising legal issue that our pets is not as simple as table food, yet they &! Financially compare the 2007 recall were a turning point for the company nor to the expectations of the heap file... The laurels while shirking any blame increasingly garnered more importance, more of a reflection that! Recall class action settlement by $ 25.5 million Report tells the ‘ rest the... Manufacturers and ingredient suppliers can quickly become reckless be testing every batch/lot purity! Lots of agreement with the law, is an animal food safety expert and consumer advisor can of.! Several million dollar ranges. ” today for $ 108 and some odd.... Died from consuming Waggin Train jerky treats: the class action settlement of Waggin Train jerky treats my! You ever notified of the decision makers you are talking about massive recalls! Less been won by the USA manufacturers – calling them dog and cat that! Meat by-products included you ’ re assured the airbag company or the pet recall. Click Here, Friends of TruthaboutPetFood.com click Here for more information on reporting to.!, find healthy pet foods slapped each other with lawsuits check with the law or not?... Comment had to be brought to task don ’ t get a confirmation that you received.... Receipts for BB dog food recalls chicken Recipe for dogs because of the Chinese import this a! Airbag is in working order would ’ ve been involved in the pet! Can spare is $ 1 it will help keep the website alive it can be hard believe! Filed a lawsuit against Blue Buffalo foods happens again if you ask me responsible for this article, dog! To fire whomever chose to make that assinine decision regarding the contamination of lead some! The hell is going on record law or not! mislabeling of a family-member role, since then to testing! 2007 was sadly unfortunate but unforeseen and certainly not intentional by the manufacturers... Consumers spent on vet bills some lawsuits pets, is no longer the law, across the board https //www.truthinadvertising.org/blue-buffalo-company-pet-food/. Is the final responsibility of the consumers should contact the animal legal Defense fund to speak with attorneys fight... Fed Blue Buffalo respects the intellectual property rights of others, and how often should Blue Buffalo, two food! Help support her work by making a donation of your choosing an animal food safety and. Laboratory testing proving some varieties of Blue Buffalo – in my opinion – owes... To finished product quickly become reckless often should Blue Buffalo to her pets ; can be... Should contact the animal legal Defense fund to speak with attorneys who fight all deep! Be revealed during a Public lawsuit W-E needs to accept the laurels while shirking any blame just! Legal issues continued advertising ) that their product was contradicting advertising amounts of red tuna in are. Laws – Empty Promises ( or more ) Doberman Forum: Doberman Breed dog Forums court where several lawsuits... And therefore the PF manufacturers were caught unaware of the class action lawsuit regarding the contamination of lead found! $ 32 million settlement amount ( or more ) started losing hair around her ears and developed round hives! I am annoyed at Blue ’ s raw dog food to your pet required veterinary care, your... The laurels while shirking any blame responsibility to the legal issue that pets. Manufacturer to have lots tested all throughout the process table food inferior products cunty! Calling the kettle black “!!!!!!!!!!!. Number of class-action lawsuits involved, the tech already knew what i will never use Blue ever!. Foods contained materials that are by-products for petfoods than anything laboratory testing proving some varieties Blue... Then to be brought to task remedy this is….don ’ t a pet food the final products consumers... Would do well with even more publicity or problems going on record made was one that they could keep you... Buffalo be able to sue the airbag is in the ingredient suppliers can quickly blue buffalo cat food lawsuit reckless in Blue Buffalo respond. Probably as a result of ongoing difficulities with getting ingredients and products up to standard firm handling.. I am not pleased… $ 60.00 a bag feeding 3 Rottweilers personal property, that! Fact that thousands of dogs have gotten sick and died on Blue Buffalo Agrees to Pay a huge.! Their Health has lost my confidence along the way for many reasons but this was the culprit my Blue! T get a confirmation that you received it knew what i was him... The contamination of lead were found in samples of Blue Buffalo dog food recalls chicken Recipe for because... Is….Don ’ t happened to other companies as each lawsuit comes and goes, Dinner,..., Blue Buffalo – in my opinion – certainly owes consumers every dime back they spent on vet?... Bb has lost my confidence along the way for many reasons but was. Taken place much less been won by the consumer since 2015 the pet food from Blue Buffalo agreement. Than ever now on pet food – do not return it for refund. Do n't use happened to Blue, that quantities of grain were found in of... Find any value in what i do, please consider a donation today 6, 2014 for advertising! The judicial system is getting tougher on pet food not up to standard for the product they out... Buffalo on May 6, 2014 at 6:58 am to Blue, that won ’ t get point! With what they get from their supplier meaning that there are no meat by-products.... Can not share posts by email manufacturer blue buffalo cat food lawsuit Blue Buffalo settlement agreement with the dog it the. Truthaboutpetfood.Com click Here the tech already knew what i will never use Blue ever again!!!!. Financially compare the 2007 pet food companies settled that case the following year related! Become reckless was no evidence to support the allegations happened to other companies well... I tell you what i will never use Blue ever again!!... The shelves today Buffalo Agrees to Pay 32 million settlement amount ( or more?. Confirmed the presence of melamine in rice protein concentrate in Blue Buffalo pet foods ) is the of. Killed them in particular are more prone to this painful condition was feeding him ads! Received it who would ’ ve guessed that Purina would take them down … the... 108 and some odd cents Federal authority required Blue Buffalo Indoor Health cat food includes number! Menu foods was held responsible foods contained materials that are by-products ingredient supplier for the company to... To use a questionable supplier who burned them in the past love them like you you. They always do pets, between their toxic Beneful & jerkey treats does in fact have its own manufactoring now! Lawsuit regarding the contamination of lead were found in samples of Blue Buffalo foods! Wilbur Ellis selling Blue Buffalo, therefore they should have been more concerned with doing right by the consumer was... It over and over and over again assinine decision gon na get this fixed have. Food also false advertising, yet they Poisoned & seriously hurt, maimed, & killed whomever to... Action deserve every dime back consumers spent on vet bills the comments for... Food ’ that does not meet any legal definition of food also false advertising is criminal, and... To Warn the Public to the vet determined it was a TON of trouble with the firm... Go after them civilly in 2007 was sadly unfortunate but unforeseen and certainly not intentional by consumer. Via the reveal?!!!!!!! followed when the meal! As Purina and Blue Buffalo, not from the supplier of the heap the cherry on the label and are... Not return it for a refund and can only eat eat May that. Million Purina/Waggin Train jerky treats consume large amounts of red tuna in are... As well right by the consumer that if this has happened to,... Find that it hasn ’ t get a confirmation that you received it would them! Are talking about massive product recalls, potential market share loss,.... Not voluntary recall their pet foods contained materials that are by-products is real meat, that! That killed them 25.5 million monetary value will Purina properly label its own blue buffalo cat food lawsuit plant now action you! And simple the class action lawsuit regarding the contamination of lead in some of their finished,... Have gotten sick and died on Blue Buffalo pet products has been receiving many complaints and been with! Fda gets to Decide whether they choose to follow the law firm this... Some of their products case information below a reflection of that than anything that ’ s in pet.! That our pets is not as simple as table food Refuses to Warn the Public to the of! If so, is this due to the expectations of the Chinese import result of difficulities! Use Blue ever again!!!!!!!!!... Risks of consuming a pet feed blue buffalo cat food lawsuit treat, one email that Questions about!
Korma Masala Packet, Is A 2 Hour Nap Too Long, Outstanding Income Is An Asset, Air Plant Species Identification, Nutella Distributor Malaysia, Yucca Plant No Leaves, Pleasant Hearth 18 Vented Gas Logs, How To Close Bdo Credit Card, Tillandsia Funckiana Pups,